Peer Review Policy

1. Purpose and Scope

This policy governs the scholarly evaluation workflows, stakeholder responsibilities, and editorial decision-making mechanisms for all submissions to EDUBA: Journal of Society, Labour and Policy Studies (EDUBA). It strictly adheres to the core practices of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), international standards, and ULAKBİM TR Index journal evaluation criteria.

The policy applies to research articles, review articles, policy briefs/short communications, technical notes, and field/case reports. Editorials, book reviews, corrections (erratum/corrigendum), and letters to the editor are not subject to external peer review; such contributions are assessed directly by the Editorial Board and explicitly designated as "Not Peer-Reviewed" upon publication.

2. Review Model

EDUBA operates a double-anonymous peer review model. The identities of authors are withheld from reviewers, and the identities of reviewers are withheld from authors throughout the process. Reviewer identities remain confidential unless explicit written consent is granted by the reviewer.

Authors must ensure that the main manuscript file is prepared for anonymous evaluation:

  • Author names, affiliations, email addresses, and ORCID identifiers must be entirely removed from the main manuscript text.

  • Acknowledgments, funding declarations, grant numbers, and specific institutional ethics committee identifiers must be placed solely on the separate Title Page.

  • Self-citations must be framed in the third person; statements like "as we previously showed" must be avoided.

  • File metadata and document properties (e.g., the "Author" field in Word or PDF properties) must be cleared.

  • Links to shared research data, code, or online supplementary materials must be provided in anonymized form (e.g., OSF anonymous view-only links or restricted repository tokens).

3. The Review Workflow

3.1. Initial Screening (Technical and Ethical Check)

Within 7 working days of submission, the editorial secretariat verifies:

  • Alignment with the journal's aim and scope,

  • Compliance with author guidelines, formatting templates, and citation standards,

  • Complete manuscript anonymization,

  • Inclusion of ethics committee approvals, informed consent documentation, and necessary institutional permissions where applicable,

  • Inclusion of mandatory statements: author contributions (CRediT), conflicts of interest, funding sources, and generative AI disclosures,

  • Plagiarism and similarity screening using Turnitin/iThenticate. Excluding references and formal quotes, overall similarity must remain below 20%, with no single source exceeding 5%. The report undergoes qualitative editorial appraisal; raw similarity scores alone do not trigger outright desk rejection unless textual overlap constitutes actual plagiarism or intellectual appropriation.

Incomplete submissions are unsubmitted and returned to authors for correction. Manuscripts falling outside the journal scope, lacking scholarly merit, or repeatedly failing formal standards are concluded via desk rejection without external review.

3.2. Editorial Assessment

Manuscripts clearing preliminary screening are assigned by the Editor-in-Chief to a Section Editor. The Section Editor assesses the manuscript's originality, methodological soundness, and thematic contribution, recommending either progression to external peer review or desk rejection. The final handling authority resides with the Editor-in-Chief.

3.3. Reviewer Assignment
  • A minimum of two independent external reviewers are assigned to each manuscript.

  • Reviewers must hold a doctoral degree (Ph.D. or equivalent) and possess demonstrable scholarly expertise and publications in the manuscript's subject domain.

  • Reviewers must represent different institutions; neither may share an institutional affiliation with the authors.

  • Reviewers are given 7 days to accept or decline an invitation. Unanswered invitations are automatically revoked, and alternate reviewers are recruited.

  • Authors may suggest up to two preferred reviewers and/or request the exclusion of up to two individuals with legitimate justification. Such suggestions are non-binding; reviewer selection remains an exclusive editorial prerogative.

3.4. Conflicts of Interest

Reviewers must recuse themselves from evaluating a submission if any of the following circumstances exist:

  • Co-authorship, collaborative research projects, or doctoral advisory relationships with any author within the preceding three years,

  • Shared current institutional affiliation,

  • Familial relationships, close personal associations, or professional disputes,

  • Direct financial or competing interests related to the research.

Editors recuse themselves from managing submissions where personal or professional ties exist. Submissions authored by the Editor-in-Chief, Associate Editors, or Editorial Board members are managed entirely by an independent guest editor. The contributing board member has no editorial access to the submission file in OJS, and this independent workflow is declared on the published article.

3.5. Review Timelines
  • Reviewers are allocated 21 days to submit their evaluation. A single 14-day extension may be granted upon justified request.

  • Automated and manual reminders are issued for overdue reports. If no feedback is secured within a subsequent 14 days, the assignment is cancelled and a replacement reviewer is appointed.

  • The targeted turnaround time to communicate a first editorial decision is 8 weeks from initial submission.

3.6. Evaluation Dimensions

Using the structured evaluation rubric within OJS, reviewers appraise submissions across the following criteria:

  1. Alignment between title, abstract, and manuscript content,

  2. Problem articulation, contextual novelty, and theoretical/practical contribution,

  3. Methodological validity, reproducibility, and rigor,

  4. Data authenticity, adequacy of statistical/qualitative analyses, and discussion of uncertainty,

  5. Presentation of empirical evidence (clarity of tables, figures, and avoidance of redundancy),

  6. Coherence of findings with the discussion, avoiding overclaiming,

  7. Substantive grounding of conclusions and transparent articulation of research limitations,

  8. Quality, relevance, and accuracy of cited references,

  9. Academic writing, clarity of expression, and structural flow,

  10. Strict adherence to ethical principles in human/field research.

Reviewers provide two tiers of feedback: (i) constructive, reasoned evaluations shared with the authors, and (ii) confidential remarks and formal recommendations intended solely for the handling editors.

3.7. Decision Categories
Decision Operational Definition
Accept Suitable for publication without further revision.
Minor Revision Minor stylistic, textual, or limited substantive amendments required; external re-review is optional.
Major Revision Substantial methodological, empirical, or interpretive revisions required; the revised version is reassessed by the original reviewers.
Resubmit for Review Unacceptable in its present structure; may be reconsidered as a new submission only following fundamental restructuring.
Reject Not acceptable for publication in EDUBA.

When reviewer recommendations diverge, an independent third reviewer is appointed. The Editor-in-Chief renders the final decision based on the substantive merits of the scientific arguments rather than a mechanical vote tally. At least two favorable peer reviews are required for publication.

3.8. Revision Process
  • Authors are given 15 days for minor revisions and 30 days for major revisions. Reasonable extension requests may be accommodated.

  • Authors must upload a detailed, point-by-point response document detailing how each reviewer critique was addressed, alongside a tracked-changes copy of the revised manuscript.

  • Authors may dispute a reviewer recommendation provided they offer robust, scientifically justified reasoning.

  • Revised manuscripts not submitted within the designated timeframe are treated as withdrawn. Subsequent submissions must be initiated as new entries.

3.9. Post-Acceptance Production

Accepted manuscripts proceed through copyediting, layout typesetting, DOI registration with Crossref, and XML/PDF production. Authors review final galley proofs strictly to correct typographical, formatting, or layout errors; substantive conceptual changes require formal authorization from the Editor-in-Chief.

4. Reviewer Responsibilities

  • Confidentiality: Submissions under review are privileged documents. Reviewers may not distribute, duplicate, discuss, quote, or appropriate any data or ideas contained in unpublished manuscripts. All downloaded files must be purged after concluding the evaluation.

  • Generative Artificial Intelligence: Reviewers must not upload manuscripts or parts thereof into external generative AI platforms or services that do not offer ironclad confidentiality and data ownership guarantees. The scholarly critique must stem from the reviewer’s direct expertise. If AI tools are employed strictly for stylistic editing of review comments, this usage must be disclosed to the handling editor.

  • Impartiality: Evaluations must focus solely on scientific merit, methodology, and evidence, unaffected by the authors’ institutional affiliations, nationality, gender, seniority, or theoretical perspective.

  • Constructive Demeanor: Critiques must be intellectually grounded, polite, actionable, and free from derogatory language or personal attacks.

  • Reporting Ethical Violations: Suspected plagiarism, data falsification/fabrication, image manipulation, duplicate publication, salami slicing, or unauthorized data usage must be reported confidentially and directly to the editor. Reviewers must never contact authors directly.

  • Citation Integrity: Reviewers must never mandate or suggest citations to their own publications simply to inflate citation metrics. Reference recommendations must be justified by immediate relevance to the manuscript.

5. Author Responsibilities

  • Submissions must represent original, unpublished research not currently under review by another journal. Prior presentation in conference proceedings (abstract only) or preprint repository postings is permissible provided it is declared upon submission.

  • Authorship lists must conform strictly to ICMJE/COPE guidelines. Modifying author names, ordering, or affiliations after submission requires formal written consent from all authors, explicit justification, and the written approval of the Editor-in-Chief.

  • For research requiring institutional review, the formal ethics committee name, approval date, and protocol number must appear in the Methodology section.

  • Authors must include a clear Data Availability Statement.

  • Generative AI Statement: Generative AI tools (LLMs) cannot be attributed authorship. Where AI technologies are used to support text drafting, coding, or data processing, their exact role must be disclosed in a dedicated statement. Stylistic proofreading assistance must likewise be acknowledged.

6. Appeals and Complaints

Authors may lodge a formal appeal against an editorial decision within 7 days of notification by providing a substantiated letter presenting scientific counter-evidence against reviewer critiques. Appeals are adjudicated by an independent editor not involved in the original decision; external arbitrators may be engaged if warranted. Final appeal decisions are definitive.

Complaints regarding operational delays, editorial conduct, or publication ethics are processed under the journal’s Complaints and Feedback Policy following COPE flowcharts. Complaints concerning senior editorial members are independently adjudicated by the BAUDER Publication Ethics Committee.

7. Post-Publication Review and Corrections

Inquiries or critiques regarding published works are investigated by the Editor-in-Chief. As appropriate, an erratum/corrigendum, formal expression of concern, or retraction will be issued in alignment with COPE Retraction Guidelines. Retracted articles remain permanently available in the archive to preserve the historical scholarly record, marked with prominent "RETRACTED" watermarks.

8. Reviewer Recognition

EDUBA recognizes peer review as an essential academic service. Formal review certificates are provided upon request, and reviewer activities may be authenticated through ORCID and Web of Science Reviewer Recognition workflows. A consolidated, non-attributed list of contributing reviewers is published annually in the journal’s closing volume.

9. Editorial Transparency and Policy Review

EDUBA publishes annual editorial statistics on its website, including total submissions, desk rejection rates, peer-reviewed rejection rates, and average turnaround timelines. This policy document is reviewed and updated at least biennially.