Ethical Principles and Publication Policy
EDUBA: Journal of Society, Labour and Policy Studies (EDUBA) adheres to the highest standards of publication ethics and scholarly integrity, strictly adopting the core practices and guidelines established by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and the recommendations of relevant international bodies.
1. Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers
Peer reviewers play a foundational role in safeguarding the integrity, rigor, and scholarly quality of published research. Reviewers are expected to adhere to the following principles:
Professional Responsibilities
-
Field Expertise: Reviewers should only accept evaluation invitations for manuscripts that strictly match their scientific expertise.
-
Confidentiality: All manuscripts received for review are privileged, confidential documents. They must not be retained, shared, circulated, or discussed with external parties without explicit authorization from the Editor-in-Chief.
-
Timeliness: Reviewers should accept invitations only if they can complete the review within the specified timeline (21 days). Any unforeseen delays must be reported immediately to the editorial office.
-
Conflict of Interest: Reviewers must decline the assignment or immediately disclose to the editor any existing financial, institutional, personal, or collaborative ties with the authors or the work under review.
Conducting the Review
-
Objectivity & Fairness: Reviews must be conducted objectively. Personal remarks, hostile criticism, or offensive commentary directed at the authors are strictly unacceptable.
-
Constructive Feedback: Critiques must be substantiated with clear scholarly reasoning and evidence, aiming constructively to help authors enhance the scientific quality of their work.
-
Evidence vs. Opinion: Reviewers must clearly delineate between evidence-based critiques supported by literature/data and subjective interpretations.
-
Anonymity: In accordance with the double-anonymous peer review model, reviewers must not disclose their identities, affiliations, or identifying document metadata within the review file.
Review Rubric: Originality, Methodological Rigor, Clarity and Readability, Structural Coherence, Adequacy of References, and Ethical Compliance.
Recommendation Options: Accept · Minor Revision · Major Revision · Resubmit for Review · Reject.
2. Ethical Guidelines for Authors
-
Originality & Plagiarism: Submitted manuscripts must represent original, unpublished scholarly research. Redundant publication, self-plagiarism (text-recycling), and plagiarism in any form are strictly prohibited. All submissions are automatically screened using plagiarism-detection software (Turnitin/iThenticate). The maximum acceptable similarity rate is 20% (excluding references), with no single external source exceeding 5%. Manuscripts that exceed this threshold or contain uncredited textual appropriation are returned or desk-rejected. Concurrent submission to multiple journals is strictly prohibited.
-
Authorship & Intellectual Contribution: Authorship is restricted to individuals who have made substantial intellectual contributions to the work, meeting all of the following criteria:
-
Substantial contributions to the conception, study design, data acquisition, or analysis and interpretation of data;
-
Drafting the manuscript or critically revising it for substantive intellectual content;
-
Final approval of the version submitted and to be published;
-
Agreement to be personally accountable for all aspects of the work in ensuring that questions related to data accuracy or research integrity are properly investigated and resolved.
All listed authors must confirm and approve the final text before submission. Any modification to authorship (adding, removing, or reordering authors) after submission requires written justification, unanimous signed consent from all original and newly added authors, and the formal approval of the Editor-in-Chief. Post-publication requests are handled strictly in accordance with the journal’s Corrections, Expressions of Concern, and Retractions Policy.
The corresponding author ensures all contributors meet authorship criteria, coordinates all editorial correspondence, and confirms collective approval. Contributors who do not meet all four authorship criteria (e.g., individuals who provided purely technical assistance, language proofreading, funding acquisition, or general department supervision) must be recognized in the Acknowledgements section with their prior consent, rather than listed as authors.
-
-
Data Access & Retention: Authors may be requested by the editorial board or reviewers to present raw or anonymized research data, interview transcripts, or analytical scripts during review. Authors are encouraged to deposit data in trusted public repositories.
-
Competing Interests: All authors must explicitly declare any financial, commercial, institutional, or personal ties that could influence the study's execution or findings. If no competing interests exist, this must be explicitly stated (e.g., "The authors declare no competing interests."). This declaration is published in the full text of every article.
-
Ethics Committee Approval & Informed Consent: Empirical research involving human participants, field interviews, surveys, or animal models must hold documented ethics approval from an independent institutional ethics review board. The approving body’s full name, decision date, and protocol number must be disclosed in the Methodology section. Written or documented informed consent must have been secured from all participants prior to data collection.
3. Role and Responsibilities of the Editor
The Editor-in-Chief and Associate Editors hold sole responsibility for deciding which manuscripts submitted to EDUBA are published. Manuscripts are appraised exclusively on their academic merit, methodological validity, originality, and thematic relevance, without regard to the authors' nationality, race, gender, institutional seniority, religious beliefs, or theoretical affiliation. The editorial office guarantees that every eligible submission undergoes rigorous double-anonymous evaluation by at least two independent peer reviewers.
4. International Standards and Frameworks
EDUBA strictly follows international publication benchmarks:
-
COPE Core Practices: Committee on Publication Ethics (https://publicationethics.org)
-
ICMJE Recommendations: International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (http://www.icmje.org)
-
TÜBİTAK ULAKBİM TR Dizin: Evaluation Criteria for Scholarly Journals
5. Responsible Research Assessment (DORA & CoARA)
The journal’s publisher and owner, BAUDER (Bilimsel Araştırmalar ve Uygulamalar Derneği), is an active member of the Coalition for Advancing Research Assessment (CoARA) and a proud signatory of the San Francisco Declaration on Research Assessment (DORA). In accordance with these commitments, EDUBA evaluates all submitted research strictly on its intrinsic quality, methodological soundness, and societal/intellectual contribution. The journal firmly rejects using journal-level metrics (such as the Journal Impact Factor) as a surrogate proxy for individual article quality or researcher competence.
6. Policy on the Use of Artificial Intelligence (AI)
For Authors:
-
The use of generative artificial intelligence and large language models (LLMs) in manuscript preparation—beyond routine spelling, grammar correction, and structural copyediting—must be explicitly disclosed under a dedicated "Artificial Intelligence Statement" in the manuscript.
-
The declaration must specify the exact AI model/tool used, version number, and the precise scope of its implementation (e.g., data analysis assistance, script generating, preliminary drafting).
-
Authors remain solely and completely accountable for the factual accuracy, intellectual integrity, and originality of all content, including avoiding fabricated citations or biased interpretations introduced by AI tools.
-
Generative AI technologies and LLMs cannot be listed as authors or co-authors, nor can they be cited as primary authoritative scholarly sources.
For Peer Reviewers and Editors:
-
Peer reviewers and editors must exercise strict caution regarding generative AI. Reviewers must never upload unpublished manuscripts, abstracts, figures, or proprietary data into public or unverified commercial AI platforms, as this constitutes a direct breach of confidentiality and intellectual property rights.
-
The intellectual evaluation, substantive critiques, and recommendation decisions must originate directly from the reviewer’s and editor’s professional expertise.
-
The use of AI utilities strictly for preliminary grammar refinement or linguistic translation of review reports is permissible only if explicitly declared to the Editor-in-Chief.