Corrections, Expressions of Concern, and Retractions Policy
EDUBA: Journal of Society, Labour and Policy Studies (EDUBA) adheres to the guidelines established by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) to maintain the integrity and reliability of the scholarly record.
-
Corrections (Erratum / Corrigendum): When a published article contains minor errors (such as factual inaccuracies, typographical mistakes, or minor metadata/author affiliation errors) that affect the scientific record but do not undermine the conclusions or validity of the findings, a formal correction notice is published. The notice is bi-directionally linked to the original article and clearly indicated in both HTML and PDF versions.
-
Expression of Concern: When substantive concerns arise regarding the reliability, methodology, or ethical integrity of an article, and an official investigation is either ongoing or inconclusive, the Editor-in-Chief may issue a formal Expression of Concern to alert readers and the scholarly community.
-
Retraction: An article will be retracted if:
-
Clear evidence demonstrates that the findings are unreliable, whether resulting from misconduct (e.g., data fabrication, falsification, image manipulation) or honest error (e.g., critical calculation or experimental errors),
-
The work contains plagiarism or constitutes redundant/duplicate publication,
-
The research was conducted without mandatory institutional ethical approvals or informed consent,
-
Substantial, undisclosed conflicts of interest are found to have compromised the integrity of the peer review, editorial decision-making, or scientific conclusions.
-
-
Assessment of Conflicts of Interest: An undisclosed conflict of interest does not automatically trigger an outright retraction. If an emerging or newly disclosed conflict is determined not to have compromised the validity of the data or conclusions, the journal will publish an amendment or correction. If the investigation remains pending, an Expression of Concern may be issued in the interim.
-
Archival Preservation of Retracted Works: In accordance with international digital preservation standards, retracted articles are never completely removed from the journal website or online archives. Instead, the original PDF is watermarked with "RETRACTED" on every page, and a formal retraction statement detailing the rationale and responsible parties is permanently appended to the article page.
-
Post-Publication Discussions: Scholarly discourse and post-publication critique are encouraged. Readers, researchers, and reviewers may submit substantive comments, critiques, or technical questions concerning published works directly to the Editor-in-Chief.
-
Contact for Post-Publication Inquiries:
Email: [email protected]